A book review of “Wine for Normal People”

by  |  18-01-2021  |  4 Comments

Writing an introductory text on wine is no small feat. A book that takes someone from, “Sure, I like wine, top me off!” to “Lemme breakdown the Médoc for you.” is a journey spanning two pretty distant points from one another and is why so few people to take on this Herculean task.

But I would say the hardest aspect in all of this is actually getting people to pick up and read such a book. I refer to my baseline in all such things, my mom. She was happy to churn through the pages of “Buddhism for Dummies” but when I suggested she look into “Wine for Dummies” to get a better handle on things, she passed on the opportunity, preferring to ask me whenever she has a question which is fine if it means I get out of having to troubleshoot her computer problems remotely.

People just want to drink wine and not think about it, which I really can’t blame them for. It seems to be the case that those who write a successful introductory wine text (whether that means financially, creating something of merit, or hopefully both) have established a following of people who enjoy their approach to taking on such an onerous, yet delicious topic as wine. History has shown that learning about wine proves to revolve more around a cult of personality than anything else whether that’s a classic example such as Jancis Robinson, newer media like Gary Vaynerchuk, or then whatever “influencer” may be the flash in the pan at the moment.

And so we come to Elizabeth Schneider, who, along with her husband “MC Ice” have been doing the Wine for Normal People Podcast for exactly 10 years now although the accompanying blog started in 2009. That means Elizabeth has been doing a podcast loooong before all these others decided that people wanted to hear what they have to say in a rambling, unedited fashion due to confinement during the pandemic.

In having been such a stalwart, she’s amassed a loyal following. Why? If you listen to any of her podcasts, you can immediately see why as she talks about wine in a friendly, conversational manner that people can relate to. Sounds easy and there have been others who started off this way, but then fell head deep into the cesspool of wine twattery quite quickly. Elizabeth has not succumbed to this (probably as she finds release in her aptly-labeled “geek” podcasts) and, as often happens with such ventures she created a book, unsurprisingly titled, “Wine for Normal People” that was released in 2019.

Obviously shifting from the 45-50 minute podcast format that people can listen to in the background to a text wherein people have to actively read to gain information is a big shift up in terms of format. I have to tell you that I’ve read a lot of texts that purport to do what Elizabeth has taken on here and many of them fail. Elizabeth’s simply does not.

She’s managed to keep a conversational tone throughout the text, embodying her podcasts remarkably well. For example in a brief mention about biodynamic farming she says, “I know biodynamic farming sounds kind of out there.” to show she knows what people are thinking when they hear about burying cow horns packed with manure in the field.

She also has great little pullout quotes and sidebars to keep people interested. For example she says that in general, the lighter the color of wines in both red and white, the lighter in alcohol they’ll be. To be honest, I’d never really thought about this, but she’s very much right and it’s one of these great nuggets that gives people something to grab on to whilst traversing the vast chasm of wine knowledge intake.

But I think more than anything else, it’s the fact that the book looks sharp. It’s well designed to be clean without being cutesy. It rivals another text that intends to simplify wine learning and which people always applaud for the design. In the case of Wine for Normal People, it not only looks good but actually has accurate information which is something that the other text is vastly deficient in.

Is it a quick read? No, because it can’t be. But it does overall excel in brevity as much as possible and I like the fact that in the Germany section Elizabeth flat-out says that German wines are difficult. She tries to cover it in as much detail as makes sense just so that people are aware of them and have some text as reference, but by acknowledging they’re not easy has probably helped many a reader to breathe easier.

I’d say that if Elizabeth were to publish a newer edition at some point, she could perhaps work to slow down how fast the knowledge ramps up. This is difficult as too slow and people get bored but too fast and people get overwhelmed. As it sits, it flirts with being a bit much on the latter but just a little and I say this with full admonition this is an extremely hard thing to pull off. About the only text I’ve ever seen do this perfectly was “The 24-hour Wine Expert” by Jancis Robinson and that’s only due to massive amounts of information being left out in order to give a very slim, quick overview of things.

The only final item I would put up for critique are the pronunciations. Being American myself, I know that we have a massive phobia of saying words incorrectly. But the word pronunciations used in the book aren’t based upon the International Phonetic Alphabet (which is what Wikipedia uses, for instance), and a number of them are actually approximations and thus in strict terms incorrect such as sommelier which has been written as “summ-uhl-yay” after dismissing the actual French pronunciation which is one of my pet peeves – it drives me as crazy much like when Spaniards call Facebook, “Fah-the-book”.

Of course, you can just skip these bits and in fact, this is designed to be a reference book so you can easily take away from it whatever parts you want, whenever you want and for that, it’s easily one of the best introductory wine texts available today.

★★★★☆

Review copy provided by the publisher

Please also see the Complete List of Wine Book Reviews

Newsletter
Comments

4 responses to “A book review of “Wine for Normal People””

  1. Ross Baldassaro says:

    Miquel, I was glad to see you review Elizabeth’s book; even gladder to see that your support its quality. Being someone who happily devours high quality podcasts on the world of wine and other alcoholic beverages, I have certainly listened to my fair share of Wine for Normal People podcast episodes. For me personally, my listening experience has consistently swayed between the range of “hey there is really great content here”… to “meh, another lengthy topic bit, focused on subjectively boring overtalk.” However, I truly appreciate her place and contribution to the world of wine, and for the past two years I have been contributing to her monthly Patreon account as sort of a “Hey, I appreciate all of your work, and even if I don’t always love your content, you are a smart, effective professional in this industry and we truly need more people like you.” That being said, I still haven’t purchased Elizabeth’s namesake book, but perhaps will add it to my growing stock of books I have purchased and remain in queue to read (SMH). Overall, very glad to see that you took the time to read and review her fairly new book; it’s a great win to see that you support her efforts as a solid segway to get more people interested in falling in love with pairing life with wine.

    • Miquel Hudin says:

      Admittedly, I should have reviewed it some time back, but somehow lost the digital version I was sent and had to embarrassedly request it again. Thankfully it finally saw the light of day.

      I think it’s a pretty crucial book to have out there as one that shall not be named dominates so much space and is truly shit. So a well-written, engaging book that does a great fly over of the wine world for people new to it, is a welcome addition to the landscape and I hope more people make use of it.

      For you, I’d say that it’s going to be a lot of review over what you already know. It’s definitely geared towards that kind of WSET 2 sort of level with a bit of deeper content for those who are looking for it. Fine level to be at though and the issue is that once you get out of this, you start delving into specific regional books that are pretty heavy reading. Probably half my library is full of these.

      Otherwise, enjoy the podcast. The good ones are definitely food for the soul during these times when we’re all boxed in!

  2. Ken Rupar says:

    Just listened to my first podcast. Being a visually oriented person I tend to prefer reading articles than listening to people. That is why I appreciate the additional information that is given, such as pictures and maps, which I can view at the same time on the computer. The knowledge level (in this particular podcast) was a little basic for me – although who cannot use a bit of review of basic knowledge from time to time? I enjoyed the familiar conversational tone and clear explanations, but I was a little annoyed by what I felt was a lot of “fluff” in the discussion – I tend to prefer presentations that get right down to the subject at hand. My own presentations are probably a bit dry for that reason. That is something to work on.

    • Miquel Hudin says:

      Admittedly, I’m not a big podcast listener either. Some people like them on in the background, but I just find it distracting and I don’t really take the much away from it. I find that I can read faster than I can listen to someone and I definitely agree with you that there are MANY out there which suffer from a lack of editing and too much talking.

Leave a Reply to Ross Baldassaro Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.